Breakingviews – Musk’s next disruption: accounting for crypto

Tesla Inc CEO Elon Musk walks future to a screen showing an picture of Tesla Product 3 motor vehicle throughout an opening ceremony for Tesla China-produced Design Y plan in Shanghai, China January 7, 2020. REUTERS/Aly Track

NEW YORK (Reuters Breakingviews) – Elon Musk is in no way shy of producing a bit more disruption. The entrepreneur’s $808 billion electric powered-car company, Tesla, reported on Monday that it has set $1.5 billion into bitcoin and might quickly acknowledge the cryptocurrency from potential buyers of its autos. It’s proper up Musk’s avenue as a wink to digital-expense, anti-institution fervor. But it’s also a really serious obstacle to something mainstream: in this scenario, accounting regulations.

Bitcoin surged to a file greenback worth higher than $44,000 following Tesla’s disclosure. But Musk’s company won’t mark up the achieve or any subsequent uplift in the price of its holdings. The described worth can only go down.

If that sounds odd, it is. Like payments team Square, for instance, Tesla has to account for its bitcoin holdings as so-termed indefinite-lived intangible assets, a classification far more usually for models and trademarks. That signifies they should be prepared down in the event of impairments, which consist of buying and selling rates reduced than cost. They are by no means penned up once more. Gains, if any, arrive only when assets are bought.

The current accounting process follows a method of elimination. Cryptocurrencies like bitcoin do not fulfill the definition of cash, which among other factors involves sovereign-governing administration backing. They also don’t in good shape the standard condition of a financial instrument. And they aren’t tangible belongings that may be defined as inventory.

However bitcoin is a little bit like digital hard cash. It is akin to a currency, as well, albeit unstable, illiquid and issued by an algorithm. If it is neither of people, it is a good deal like a speculative economical instrument. For people who see it as an inflation hedge, it’s a kind of digital gold.

Ideal now, the accounting is not aligned with any of all those. If crypto investments by businesses catch on, that will certainly have to improve. After all, Bitcoin’s risky value arguably will make it more probably Tesla’s documented carrying worth will ratchet downward, even if the electronic asset’s selling price spikes to new highs.

Consider a future Tesla with big holdings of bitcoin truly worth significantly far more than they price tag. The organization would report an asset benefit based, fundamentally, on the lowest buying and selling cost of the cryptocurrency given that it was acquired. That would be deceptive and give professionals a potentially massive pot of obscured gains to play with. Musk may possibly take pleasure in that adaptability. But buyers and accounting standard-setters shouldn’t.


Reuters Breakingviews is the world’s foremost supply of agenda-placing fiscal insight. As the Reuters brand name for fiscal commentary, we dissect the large business and economic stories as they split around the world each and every day. A world wide team of about 30 correspondents in New York, London, Hong Kong and other major towns gives expert analysis in authentic time.

Sign up for a cost-free demo of our total service at and comply with us on Twitter @Breakingviews and at All viewpoints expressed are people of the authors.